A Writing Journey

****Spoiler Warning**** This post will contain spoilers for the TV show through the most recent season. Read with caution.

So I finished watching this most recent season of GoT this week (is this only season 5?) and I’ve got to say, I’ve got some pretty dissatisfied feelings. This dissatisfaction stems from 2 places: 1) the killing of pretty much every character that is a “main” character and 2) the increased violence, sex, and sexual violence.

On the first point. The beheading of Ned in season one, that was a good plot twist. The killing of Tywin last season was much needed, as was the killing of Joffrey. The destruction of the Starks in the Red Wedding was, despite it’s graphic and depressing nature, important to the story. Poisoning Marcella? Burning Shireen alive? Stabbing Jon Snow in a Ceasar-esque fashion? These things (all at the end of this most recent season) crossed a line with the killing. I’ll get to that line in a moment. First I’d like to talk about why killing character willy-nilly doesn’t work in fiction.

Despite what many writing sites will tell you about “killing your darlings,” you don’t have to kill characters to make  a story good. Some people even think it diminishes the story. I am a proponent of balance. Here is the thing about GoT: they get you invested in a character, invested in where their particular story is going, and then BAM! Another bloody throat. Evey time this happens to a main character, investment in the story at large decreases. As my boyfriend said at Jon’s death “Now I’m not going to care about anything that happens at the Wall.” And it’s true. If you kill the characters people are attached to, the ones you have followed for seasons (or chapters) and made them into a main (not supporting-main*) character, killing them is NOT a good idea. And I say this even though I did not particularly care for Jon Snow. He was, in my opinion, too goodey-two-shoes. And yet his death has made me non-inclined to watch the next season.

In order for a story to work, readers or viewers must have someone in the story that they care about, that they relate to, that they are invested in. G.R.R. Martin takes that away every chance he gets. He kills off the characters just to prove he can, or perhaps because he sees no other way to remove their floundering plot line. Here’s the thing, it makes the story very realistic. In wars, people die all the time. Important people die. But this is supposed to be a story. There is a fine line between too fictional and too realistic. That’s the line we’ve got to walk. And in that line is the implicit promise of the writer to the reader/viewer that the person they care about will, somehow, come out on the other side. That they won’t lose everyone.

So that line Martin crossed with killing the girls? That comes to my second point**. I think the author has some problems, to dwell so much on the things he dwells on. Maybe this judgement isn’t fair of me, as I know that writers write the story and sometimes there are graphic details. HOWEVER. So much violence, so much sex, and so much sexual violence is a problem. These things have taken over to the point where there is no longer a clear story, but rather a string of violence and sex mashed together with the barest of plots. And killing little girls (killing any children) can be problematic in a story. Yes, it potentially has a place, in order to set a tone, but I don’t believe it was needed here. I believe that his stories are filled with violence for the sake of violence, sex for the sake of sex, and sexual violence for the sake of sexual violence.

These two things, I believe, are what is causing the show to no longer work. There is no character that can be invested in without fear of reprisal (as in: I like this character, so they will die, so it is better if I don’t like any character, thus decreasing investment in the story) and the violence of the story, sexual or otherwise, has over taken the plot until the plot barely exists anymore.

*Supporting-main characters are, to me, the characters that surround the main character. Think Ron and Hermione in Harry Potter. They are main, but they clearly are supporting to the MAIN character.

**My second point is my opinion formed through observation. I believe that the things I mention here are both evidence of our problem as society (that we accept these things as normal) and detrimental to society’s growth (that it helps us accept them as normal, and teaches (in the subtle way that popular culture does) young men and women what is okay).

Advertisements

Comments on: "Why Game of Thrones is no Longer Working" (14)

  1. I don’t watch the show, so I was interested to read your post. This does not seem like the kind of show I would watch or would even like. I understand what you mean when you say killing is senseless sometimes. Thanks for sharing

    • I originally started watching the show because there aren’t that many good fantasy tv shows or movies, and that is what I gravitate towards. That fact has kept me through a lot of issues I’ve had with the show, but I think I’m done now.

  2. I don’t watch the show, but I heard that Martin wasn’t really involved in the latest season. So it could be the show runners that are taking liberties. Never read the books either since it seems to always be described to me as a literary snuff film. I do remember hearing something about Martin associating his books more with a historical war fiction than fantasy, which might be causing some issues too. Again, never tried to get into it since it seemed to be all about killing the favorite characters.

    • I didn’t know that about the most recent season, but these issues were there from the beginning.

      • Got it. All I remember is trying during a marathon. Randomly picked times to watch when the kid wasn’t around. Stumbled onto a beheading, torture, nudity, I think a rape, and then the slaughtering of infants. Decided to find something less horrific like Walking Dead.

        • Yep, it’s pretty terrible. Especially when you stumble in like that and have no idea why it’s happening. I was put off by the first few episodes, but kept watching because it is a fantasy show.

          • I have Merlin Season 1 on DVD, so I use that for my fantasy hit. Though I’m more into Supernatural lately. I wonder if GoT will start ebbing after this last season. All I see is anger.

          • I did like Merlin, but I never got around to finishing it. I think part of the reason is that Merlin is such a well-known character – even if the show takes him in a different direction.
            Supernatural is WAY too scary for me, lol.
            I watch a lot of the sort of mixed sci-fi and fantasy stuff (like terra nova or heroes) but most of those are too “realistic,” if you know what I mean. They aren’t really sciency but they are more like dramas with a twist.
            I don’t know. Books are still the way to go – even though I’m finding it harder and harder to satisfy my literary needs. *Sigh*

          • I got into it around Season 3 and caught a bunch of marathons. One of the things I liked was that the focus was more on Merlin instead of Arthur or events around them. The banter was always fun too.

            I actually get scared easily, so horror movies are out. Supernatural does have some freaky episodes that I have trouble getting through, but it can be more gore than fear most of the time. Again, I think the banter keeps me in there. I see a trend. 🙂

            I liked Heroes until Season 2 and really wish Terra Nova kept going. It was interesting and it felt like it needed a slow start. Would have liked more dinosaurs, but there was always time for that later. Well there would have been.

          • It sounds like we have similar tastes when it comes to shows!

            Supernatural lost me when one of their episodes took place where I lived at the time! Not okay, haha!

          • I need to find out if there was a Long Island one. They tend to be in the more rural regions.

          • They usually are – the one in Toledo was the one I mentioned and that wasn’t very rural.

          • Had to look up which one that was. Definitely one of the early creepy ones.

          • Yep! That’s why it lost me, haha

Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Tag Cloud

Quiet Water Craft

Official crafty blog for my Quiet Water Craft Etsy shop

creativepixie.wordpress.com/

eat up some crafty goodness with a creative momma

My Crafty Musings

A Crochet Blog

Panda Gets Crafty

Crochet. Knit. Needle felt. Cross stitch.

my world of crocheting

"And presently I was driving through the drizzle of the dying day, with the windshield wipers in full action but unable to cope with my tears."

Masala Vegan

Plant based cruelty free recipes for cooking, baking and living from India and beyond!

Flourish & Knot

Handmade Living - Budget Decorating, DIY & Craft Tutorials, Sewing, Flower Arrangement Tutorials - Montreal, Canada DIY blog

Elephants Hankie Blog

Question everything, Explore Life, create wonder.

Crochet by Wendy

Handmade Crochet Items, Gifts and Accessories

Crochet539

Handmade, Festive Adornments

Amanda Crochets

Handmade with Love

Lime Green Lady

Crafting chatter with patterns, projects and photos.

The Crafty Mummy

DIY, Crafts and Handmade

%d bloggers like this: